Who Wore it Better at the 2009 VMAs: Pink or Shakira?

Uh oh! Same dress alert! Pink and Shakira are probably firing their stylists afterwards for not being on top of it, but gf's wore the same short leather chain link dress at the 2009 MTV VMAs. Pink kept true to her punkiness with the hair and pairing the dress with pumps. While Shakira kept her hair long and effortless and paired with with knee high boots. We give it to pink. She owns the look better. But what do you guys think?